Sermon Commentary for Sunday, November 22, 2026

Matthew 25:31-46 Commentary

Most of us are very familiar with Jesus’s promise to sort the peoples of the earth on Judgment Day—especially on this Reign of Christ or Christ the King Sunday. This moment is the end of the beginning: the earth as we know it—and everything in it—will be transformed and the Day of the Yahweh, Judgment Day, is part of the eternal future becoming established.

Jesus speaks with words that are both familiar and unfamiliar to us. Most obvious is that we know the difference between a sheep and a goat but might not understand the sorting metaphor. Both animals grazed and moved as part of the herd together during the day, but even a quick glimpse at the two animals side-by-side should make clear that sheep have a lot more hair on them and are therefore able to readily stay warm throughout the night. Goats, on the other hand, need more protection and thus need to be sorted at the end of the day so that they can be properly sheltered and taken care of by the shepherd.This story is a parable of sorts, and as such, the sorting is not the real point of the story that Jesus wants us to bring home. We know this because the idea that sheep and goats get sorted at night would not have surprised the audience. The real surprise is very clear in the text: both groups of people ask Jesus, “Lord, when was it we saw you ______?” 

Both groups of people are completely unaware, but their lives can’t be more different. One group is oblivious, detached and might as well be living on the moon. It’s like how the ultra-rich have no idea how much something costs at the corner grocery store. They don’t know and they don’t care to know or be bothered. But they could know and there is nothing stopping them from doing so. 

The other group are unaware of what they do even as they are actively present to the realities and needs around them; they are entrenched in living. They have been caught up in God’s vision of shalom and want to see it come to be with every fibre of their being. And, it seems, they have reached the point of trusting in its reality that they no longer need to keep the commands and promises that encourage and guide in front of them. In other words, they don’t need to be reminded of what they are doing or why; this has simply become who they are. That’s why they didn’t even realize that what they had done to help others was actually helping God.

There is something quite remarkable in these sorts of situations about not needing to see the image of God in another human being in order to do what is right for them—or to have the human dignity of every person—good or evil, friend or foe or stranger—so deeply inside of your psyche that it is your autopilot. There is something pure about sharing and caring as Jesus did: not because he saw himself in us, but because he loves us. 

The people whom Jesus describes as being blessed (in the perfect tense, no less) and whom he tells to inherit the kingdom that has been waiting for them since before the world was made, they have been following the path of “long obedience in the same direction.” They look and live—conduct themselves—as citizens of the Kingdom of God. They do not fear what is to come because they trust the one on its throne. Amen! Come, Lord Jesus!

Textual Point

The Greek word used here for punishment is undeniably connected to suffering because of past actions. Interestingly, the same word was used in other religions to describe the odor of the sacrifice offerings made to their gods. (Donald Hagner in the WORD Biblical Commentary)

The same Greek word is also used in 1 John 4.18: “There is no fear in love. But perfect love drives out fear, because fear has to do with punishment. The one who fears is not made perfect in love.” Unlike the other gods, we do not fear our God and his love; our reasons for punishment are burned away in his perfect love. When we live and move and have our being in him, we have the disposition needed for doing good without force or coercion.

Illustration Idea

You’ve maybe heard the same advice as me from some pulpit or book or pastoral figure: when we’re trying to figure out how much to give as an offering, we should give so that it costs us something—that it should “hurt” because if you give and never notice then you aren’t really making any sacrifice. Clearly, that’s not the approach that Jesus takes in our story as he praises those who have loved, served, and given throughout their lives to others in need and do not even realise they have done so. That’s because they weren’t really thinking about or planning their actions but simply living out of a certain disposition; they were a certain kind of person. It takes work for this way of being to become who we are, so maybe our giving does need to “hurt” at some point in our journey—but finding the joy of giving becomes its own reward.

 

 

Note: Looking ahead? In addition to our weekly sermon commentaries each Monday, check out our special Advent and Christmas Resource page for more sermon ideas and other Advent/Christmas resources. 

Tags

Preaching Connections: , , , ,
Biblical Books:

Dive Deeper

This Week:

Spark Inspiration:

Sign Up for Our Newsletter!

Insights on preaching and sermon ideas, straight to your inbox. Delivered Weekly!

Newsletter Signup
First
Last